No proposal leaves unchecked

Obstat writes research proposals and holds each one until a separate Critic has checked every claim against the person it names.

Holds rv_03

Writer 2 held, round 1

Failed on the proposal and claims 4, 5 and 6 (C3, duplicate profile).

Mirjana Jeremić trained and tested a convolutional neural network to detect hyperbolic reflections indicative of buried point and linear targets in GPR B-scans.

Authored · names R0139 · cites SYN-PUB-01827

C2 Attribution. SYN-PUB-01827’s author entries carry R0539, not R0139.

C3 Duplicate profile. SYN-PUB-01827 is attributed to R0539. R0139 and R0539 look like one person (reversed name order, same faculty). Cite R0539 or state both IDs.

Failed C2, C3

Mirjana Jeremić assessed positional discrepancies between independent GPR-based cadastre surveys and operator GIS records.

Authored · names R0139 · cites SYN-PUB-01828

Failed C2, C3

The committed run wrote 3 proposals and turned 135 challenges away, in 23 model calls.

Nihil obstat: the censor’s line that let a book go to press. Obstat prints it only after every claim checks out.

One person, stored twice in the dataset.

R0139

Jeremić Mirjana

vanredni profesor, Fakultet tehničkih nauka

Profile lists SYN-PUB-01827, 01828 and 01829

R0539

Mirjana Jeremić

Associate Professor, Faculty of Technical Sciences

The author entry on SYN-PUB-01827 carries R0539

A printed page headed Imprimatur, with a round episcopal seal and the date 4 Juni 1897, inside a red ruled border

First, a writer writes.

From the researcher’s profile, as the profile states it. Writer 2 worked from R0139, whose profile lists SYN-PUB-01827.

Then the gate holds it.

Only that writer’s loop waits. Writers 1 and 3 kept working through the hold.

Next, the Critic checks.

Ten checks, run against the records themselves. The paper’s author entry carries R0539, not R0139.

Last, it passes or returns.

A failure goes back with its reasons. In round 2 Writer 2 cited R0539, and pair-2 was written.

Ten checks on every claim

Fails when a cited ID is not in the dataset, or when the challenge belongs to another company.
Fails when the record’s author, inventor or participant entries do not carry the named researcher. In the run: SYN-PUB-01827’s author entries carry R0539, not R0139.
Fails when a claim names a second record of one person. In the run: SYN-PUB-01827 is attributed to R0539. R0139 and R0539 look like one person (reversed name order, same faculty). Cite R0539 or state both IDs.
Fails when the evidence belongs to a different person with the same name. In the dataset: SYN-PUB-09418 belongs to R0881 Nina Mamužić (Faculty of Agriculture), not R0128 (Faculty of Technology).
Fails without a quote from the researcher’s own open_to or notes, or when they left, or are emeritus and the role is not consulting. In the run: Quote the words in R0906’s open_to or notes that support this role.
Fails when commitments the gate has already passed exceed what the researcher’s note allows.
Fails when the Industry Analyst turned the challenge away as not research, or as having no fitting researcher.
Fails when a required section is missing, a marker points at no claim, or a claim is a pasted paragraph.
Fails on worth language about people: best researcher, top-ranked, scores next to names.
Fails when a small model, given only the cited records, finds they do not support the sentence.

The proposals

A pale pink Secession building with an ornate gable on Novi Sad’s main square, Trg slobode, with trees and people in front

Turned away

135 of 489 challenges, before any matching. The Analyst’s reasons, as it gave them.

Funding and grants

Zrenjanin Game Works: C002-CH3; Grant application paperwork and administrative corrections are standard administrative tasks.
AutomVoj: C003-CH3; Preparing a bankable cash-flow model and sensitivity analysis for loan application is financial consulting, not research.
PravniPilot: C006-CH2; Cap table restructuring and handling convertible note terms are legal and corporate finance tasks.

Legal and compliance

Velago Software: C011-CH2; Reviewing and negotiating client data processing agreements under GDPR is legal work.
Sentinel Byte: C012-CH3; Filing paperwork for statutory auditor registration with government ministries is administrative and legal work.
OsiguroMi: C004-CH4; Appointing a licensed intermediary and handling regulatory licensing processes are legal and administrative work.
Suncokret Eko: C007-CH2; Preparing certification paperwork and navigating scheme documentation are administrative tasks.

Hiring and training

Kvantor Inženjering: C014-CH3; Onboarding and training junior staff members is human resources and management work.
DriveLogic Vojvodina: C018-CH3; Training engineers on protocol internals and handling staff turnover are internal HR and training activities.
Sentinel Byte: C012-CH2; Designing customer training curricula and educational materials is training development work.

Sales and market entry

Elekron Sistemi: C008-CH3; Navigating foreign public procurement tenders and e-procurement portals is sales and administrative work.
Krenuti Digital: C064-CH3; Sales training and presentation coaching for founders is professional development services.
Bela Ruža Kozmetika: C089-CH3; Analyzing webshop funnel drop-offs and abandoned-cart rates is e-commerce marketing work.

No researcher in the field

Orbita Inženjering: C063-CH2; Structural dynamics and vibration fatigue analysis is a real engineering question, but the closest university groups lack matching expertise.

The Industry Analyst read all 489 challenges.
Every one turned away is in out/no-match.md.